atl_logo_white_png_RETINA
atl_logo_white_png_RETINA
Main Menu
Menu

France vs Foncière Vélizy Rose: CASE SUMMARY

Home » Case Library »

France vs Foncière Vélizy Rose: CASE SUMMARY

Case Information

  • Court: Council of State, 9th – 10th Joint Chambers, France
  • Case No.: 471147
  • Applicant: Foncière Vélizy Rose (FVR)
  • Defendant: Minister to the Prime Minister, Responsible for Budget and Public Accounts
  • Judgment Date: 8 November 2024
  • Download the FULL JUDGMENT

Judgment Summary

The Council of State reviewed an appeal by Foncière Vélizy Rose (FVR) regarding the withholding tax on an interim dividend of EUR 3.6 million distributed to Vélizy Rose Investment (VRI), a Luxembourg-based entity, which was subsequently paid to Dewnos Investment. The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal had dismissed FVR’s claim to discharge this withholding tax, prompting the appeal.

FVR argued that the withholding tax exemption under Article 119 ter of the French General Tax Code (GTC) applied as VRI qualified as the beneficial owner of the dividend. The court examined whether VRI’s status as the dividend’s beneficial owner met the conditions for the withholding tax exemption. Noting that VRI’s sole function was holding FVR’s shares and that it transferred the full dividend to Dewnos Investment the following day, the court ruled that VRI could not be deemed the beneficial owner.

FVR further contended that applying Articles 119a and 119b of the GTC infringed on the freedom of establishment under Articles 49 and 54 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The court rejected this, aligning with earlier European jurisprudence, holding that beneficial ownership requirements did not contravene EU law or directives.

The Council of State upheld the lower courts’ findings, confirming that VRI’s lack of effective beneficial ownership disqualified FVR from the withholding tax exemption. The appeal was dismissed, and the judgment underlined the critical nature of beneficial ownership in tax treaty applications.

VIEW THE FULL CASE SUMMARY (WEB)

DOWNLOAD
File Type: pdf
File Size: 202 KB
Categories: France
Tags: Beneficial Ownership, Freedom of Establishment, Tax Compliance, Tax Treaty Interpretation, Transfer Pricing
Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top

Compare Programmes

Choose the track that fits your practice focus. All programmes are practitioner-taught, cohort-based, and validated by Middlesex University.

Dimension Transfer Pricing International Taxation South African Tax Law
Jurisdictional audience Global audience, covers all jurisdictions Global audience, covers all jurisdictions South Africa specific, relevant to SADC region
Ideal for TP managers, advisors, in-house tax teams, analysts moving into TP Advisors and managers dealing with cross-border rules, treaties, planning Practitioners working with the SA Income Tax Act, cases, compliance
Core focus Methods, comparables, DEMPE, documentation, audits, dispute defence Treaties, source vs residence, anti-avoidance, PE, relief from double tax Statutory interpretation, case law, assessments, objections, local practice
Primary tools OECD TP Guidelines, UN Manual, BEPS Actions 8–10, 13, case law OECD and UN Models, MLI, BEPS 1.0 and 2.0, domestic rules, cases Income Tax Act, SARS practice notes, Tax Administration Act, SA cases
Assessment style Case-based assignments, file reviews, short written defences Problem questions, treaty interpretation, position papers Problem questions, statutory analysis, case commentary
Typical outcomes Build defensible TP files and strategies, improve audit readiness Design cross-border structures within rules, mitigate double tax Apply SA tax law accurately, manage reviews and disputes
Entry point Start with PG Certificate, progress to PG Diploma, then MSc, or enter later with suitable experience or credits.

Awards Ladder

Award Best for What you achieve Assessment highlights
PG Certificate Foundation to intermediate upskilling Core concepts, frameworks, and applied techniques Short case write ups, timed responses, applied tasks
PG Diploma Expanding technical depth and application Advanced analysis, risk management, documentation quality Integrated case assignments, policy memos, oral defence
MSc Leaders and specialists building authority Capstone project and research backed practice outcomes Research project, viva or presentation, publishable summary

IFF Certificate Courses

Practical, practitioner-led certificates designed for immediate on-the-job application. Each course can stand alone or act as a pathway into our postgraduate tracks.

Dimension Conducting a Transfer Pricing Trial Effectively Managing Tax Teams Indirect Taxation Tax Risk Management
Jurisdictional audience Global audience Global audience Global audience, with local adaptation Global audience
Ideal for In-house tax, TP managers, litigators, advisors preparing for audits, ADR, trial Heads of tax, managers, team leads, controllers, emerging leaders VAT, GST, customs, finance managers, AP, AR, compliance specialists Tax managers, risk officers, controllers, advisors building governance
Core focus Case theory, evidence files, expert reports, witness prep, courtroom strategy Operating models, KPIs, workflows, stakeholder management, coaching VAT design, place of supply, input credits, exemptions, WHT interactions Risk identification, controls, documentation, audit readiness, dispute playbooks
Delivery mode Online, live sessions plus guided self-study Online, live sessions plus guided self-study Online, live sessions plus guided self-study Online, live sessions plus guided self-study
Duration 16 weeks, part-time 16 weeks, part-time 16 weeks, part-time 16 weeks, part-time
Outcomes Confident litigation preparation and defence for TP disputes Stronger execution, clear roles, measurable team performance Reduced VAT errors, better cash flow, fewer surprises at audit Structured governance, fewer findings, faster dispute resolution
Prerequisites TP fundamentals recommended Supervisory experience helpful Basic VAT knowledge helpful General tax experience helpful
Pathway Progress to PG Certificate in Transfer Pricing Progress to Mechanics of Leading Tax Teams, PG Certificate (leadership) Progress to PG programmes, International Tax or SA Tax Law Progress to PG Certificate in International Taxation or Transfer Pricing
Assessment End of module progress assessment

5000-word assignment if PG-Cert option elected		 End of module progress assessment

5000-word assignment if PG-Cert option elected		 End of module progress assessment

5000-word assignment if PG-Cert option elected		 End of module progress assessment

5000-word assignment if PG-Cert option elected